Popular Music In America
A Perspective From 1910, Part 2
In our continuing desire to preserve the music of our past, we feel preservation
of important collateral material is also important. Therefore, in conjunction
with our two part issue on Enduring
Hit Songs Part
One & Part
Two we offer you the continuation of this special "In Search Of"
article from 1910. Within this article are contained mention of several of the
composers featured in this issue as well as many of the Parlor Songs issues
we have published over the years. We have added the illustrations and musical
links, the text is given to you as written. We hope you find it interesting
and enjoyable. It is very interesting to note that much of what this author
has said, 92 years ago, is as true today as it was then with regard to what
makes a song popular. Though this is a very long article, I felt that editing
it would only detract from its value as an historical document and deprive those
of you who are interested in its entire text. Still, owing to its length, we
will present it in two installments, this is part two. To read part one, use
POPULAR MUSIC, part 2
(Continued from Part 1, January, 2002)
Two special classes of songs, which, in a way, may be termed popular, are college
songs and gospel hymns. Of the two, the hymns more properly may be classified
as popular music, insomuch as they are sung by all sorts and conditions of people,
while the college songs are somewhat limited in their employment, although some
of them have come into general use. Many of the latter did not originate as
student songs but have been appropriated from various sources until now they
are conceded to be the especial property of the undergraduate.
The college glee club, for which many of these songs originally were indited,
is patterned after the German Männerchor, though the singing and the selections
hardly attain to the dignity of those of the Teutonic choruses. Nevertheless
excellent musical and dramatic effects, though often of an exaggerated order,
are obtained by the college men. The songs
themselves, with which most of us are familiar, contain as their most salient
feature a sharply marked rhythm, thus making them especially effective when
given in chorus. The melodies and harmonies are pleasing and catchy, while the
words usually are sentimental or humorous, certain of them being elaborations
of Mother Goose rhymes. All of the larger and older institutions have their
own individual songs which are looked upon as the special property of the student
body, both graduate and undergraduate.
Among the songs most popular with all the colleges are Gaudeamus, Integer
Vitae, Vive l'Amour, Bingo, Mary had a little Lamb, Tarpaulin Jacket, The Dutch
Company, Spanish Cavalier, Good-night, Ladies, Soldier's Farewell, Nelly was
a Lady, Old Cabin Home and scores of others. It will be seen that many of
these have been appropriated from the repertory of popular music in general,
until they have become recognized by the public as essentially "college"
songs. A special feature of student life which has given rise to many songs
has been the amateur theatricals conducted by the various societies and fraternities;
for in many of these productions, which often are written by the students themselves,
and given elaborate presentations, songs alad instrumental numbers figure prominently.
The growth of the gospel and Sunday-school hymn is the outcome of the revival
and Sunday-school movements, added to the trend of popular music in general.
In the early days of these two religious factors use was made of the ordinary
hymns and chorals of the church, but as popular secular music assumed a new
form the demand for sacred music of a similar nature had to be met. Consequently
a number of writers came forward with simple melodies, arranged with fundamental
harmonies, which they set to suitable words. Here then was the counterpart of
the popular secular song. There has been much outcry among church musicians
against the continued use of this too often trashy music and there is no question
that its spirit is far from religious; but it is music which satisfies the uncultured
taste and as such is necessary in the less formal services ofthe church. The
idea of adapting secular airs and those of a secular character to church uses
is not new, for in the time of Luther, and even earlier, similar practises were
common. In the matter of the words of the gospel hymns the same spirit is seen,
for literary culture is as necessary for the appreciation of verse of a high
character as is musical culture for true enjoyment of music of the better class.
There is as great a chance for improvement in the text of both sacred and secular
popular songs as there is in the musical settings.
Many of the gospel hymns have become extremely popular and are known the world
over. Such a hymn as Sweet Bye and Bye, by J. P. Webster, is sung wherever
the English language is heard. There are many Americans, writers of gospel hymns,
whose names have been associated almost exclusively with this branch of popular
music. Among them are Lowell Mason, P. P. Bliss, Ira D. Sankey, Phillipp Phillipps,
L. O. Emerson and Horatio R. Palmer. George F. Root wrote many popular hymns
such as Hold the Fort, Pull for the Shore and Rescue the Perishing.
was written by Charles C. Converse, while Lowell Mason's best known hymn is
Blest be the tie that binds.
Popular instrumental music in America dates practically from the period following
the Civil War. True, the dance tunes of England, Ireland and Scotland previously
had been used to display the musical attainments of the maiden of the period,
but it was not until recent years that any effort was made to satisfy the growing
demand for instrumental music of a popular style. As piano playing became more
general (for the piano is the true "home" instrument, following the
cabinet organ, which was not adapted to music of a showy character) several
writers came forward with compositions gauged to appeal to
the average musical intelligence. This music usually is formed of a simple and
pleasing melody set to elemental harmony and brightened with arpeggios and similar
stock passages, the whole capable of being performed, or executed, by players
of small attainment. The variation pieces by A. P. Wyman, T. P. Ryder, and Chas.
L. Blake, together with the operatic arrangements of James Bellak and ethers,
are representative of this class of music. Well-known melodies such as Old
Oaken Bucket, Nearer My God to Thee,
Old Black Joe, Suwanee River, Sweet Bye and Bye and others
of like character were arranged with variations. There were again other pieces,
of which Silvery Waves and Maiden's Prayer are typical of the
class, which had an immense sale and which went to form the repertory of many
an amateur pianist. At a later date came the various waltzes and marches and
still later the two-step and pieces of the intermezzo character.
Foremost among the successful American writers of popular instrumental music
stands the name of John Philip Sousa, the "March King." It has been
said that Sousa writes with
the metronome at his elbow running at one hundred and twenty clicks to the minute.
Sousa's marches never have been surpassed and rarely equaled. They are without
doubt the most typical music which this country has yet produced, for they are
indeed deeply imbued with the American spirit.' Sousa above all others has caught
the true martial swing; his music also has the stamp of his own distinct individuality
and he practically has revolutionized march music. No other composer, not even
Johann Strauss, has attained such world-wide popularity as has Sousa. His music
has been sold to thousands of bands in the United States alone and has been
heard in all parts of the civilized world. It has been very aptly stated that
Sousa's marches contain all the nuances of military psychology, the long unisonal
stride, the grip on the musket, the pride in the regiment and the esprit de
corps. They also have served as dance music, and the two-step was directly borne
into vogue by them.
John Philip Sousa was born in Washington, D. C., on Nov. 6, 1859, his mother
being a German and his father a Spanish political exile. At eight years of age
Sousa was playing the fiddle in a dancing school and at sixteen led anorchestra
in a variety theatre. Two years later he became director of a traveling theatrical
troupe, composing music for the members and also appearing in negro minstrel
roles. At nineteen he toured the country as a member of Often-bach's Orchestra,
and shortly after he became director of the Pinafore Opera Company. For some
years after this he directed the United States Marine Band and in 1892 formed
his own Concert Band. His career from this time on is familiar to the American
public. Sousa's chief claim to fame lies in his marches, from which he has derived
a princely income. The most popular of these are Washington Post, Liberty
Bell, High School Cadets, King Cotton, Manhattan Beach,
El Capitan and Stars and Stripes Forever. As will be seen, the
titles are derived either from patriotic subjects or from some subject-matter
of national import or interest. Sousa's efforts in the comic opera field receive
mention elsewhere in this chapter.
Marked advancement in the public taste for instrumental music has been shown
in recent years and many compositions of an artistic nature have been adopted
into the repertory of popular music. Pieces such as Handel's Largo,
Rubinstein's Melody in F, Nevin's Narcissus and even Schumann's
Traiumerei may now be classed as popular music. The concert bands have
done much in familiarizing the public with music of this character, and it is
no uncommon thing to find the public making special requests for the works of
Wagner and Liszt. Another feature which has tended to elevate the popular taste
for instrumental rather than for vocal music is the general study of the piano
by the young. The teaching material of necessity is of higher grade than the
songs commonly sung and America has gained much from the general introduction
of the piano into the home.
In light opera and musical comedy is seen the most elaborate phase which popular
music has assumed. Of late years the country has been deluged with musical plays
until their effect has been felt on the legitimate drama. These productions
are the natural sequence of the decadent minstrelshow, and while they lack the
dignity, if such a word may here be used, of the comic operas of the European
peoples, the American public has wafted them into favor until they have become
the most popular form of entertainment presented on the stage.
The better class of American light operas is built somewhat after the style
of those of Gilbert and Sullivan, while the "near" operas or musical
comedies are simply a series of solos, concerted pieces and choruses held together
by a mere thread of a plot. Several of the better sort have become standards
and bid fair to remain for some years to come; but the vogue of the vast majority
is fleeting, lasting at the best but for a few years.
Light opera first sprang into favor with the American public in 1878, in which
year James C. Duff, a brother-in-law of Augustin Daly, brought from England
Gilbert and Sullivan's H. M. S. Pinafore and produced it at the Standard
Theatre (now the Manhattan) in New York. The success of the charming opera was
remarkable, and as there was no copyright on the work different managers at
once took it up and within a short time five theatres in New York alone were
playing it to full houses. Such was the furore which "Pinafore'' created
that soon it was being produced in all parts of the country and by all sorts
of companies--children's, church-choir, and even negro.
When the "Pinafore" craze struck Boston a Miss Ober decided to form
a company composed of the best church and concert singers of the city in order
to produce the popular operetta in the most adequate manner possible. She was
successful in bringing together an excellent organization which took the name
of the Boston Ideal Pinafore Company. The outcome of this was the famous Bostonians,
which survived the "Pinafore" craze and which for so many years maintained
undiminished popularity. From this company came many of the best light opera
singers which this country has produced, among them being Jessie Bartlett Davis,
Adelaide Phillips, Marie Stone, H. C. Barnabee, Myron W. Whitney, Eugene Cowles
and Tom Karl. No other company of American singers ever has achieved such lasting
success as did the Bostonians. For twelve years they toured the country, season
after season, until they became a national institution. Their repertory included
all the popular light operas of their day, but DeKoven's Robin Hood became
the especial favorite, this opera receiving over a thousand performances at
The name of John A. McCaull for many years was associated with the production
of light opera in New York. When, in 1880, Pirates of Penzance was brought
out by Gilbert and Sullivan, precautionary measures were taken to prevent American
pirates from appropriating the score and an alliance with Mr. McCaull was formed
to produce the new work at the Fifth Avenue Theatre. About this time Rudolph
Aronson instituted the Casino, and for several seasons McCaull supplied the
company in which Francis Wilson was the principal comedian. Mr. McCaull then
took charge of Wallack's Theatre, and it was in this house that he made his
best productions. The stock company which he formed was of unusual excellence
and included De Wolfe Hopper, Jefferson de Angelis, Digby Bell, Laura Joyce,
Marion Manola and Eugene Ondine. So successful did the company become that its
very success led to its downfall, for the best talent too soon followed Francis
Wilson into the world of star productions, and as a result the organization
suffered a decline.
The "star" system largely was responsible for the decadence of light
opera of the better class, for good general ensemble was allowed to suffer in
order to exploit the "star" or "stars." Instead of the opera
being written as an exposition of suitable music and libretto, such as contained
in the Gilbert and Sullivan and earlier DeKoven operas, it became merely a vehicle
to bring forward this or that "star" with his or her peculiar limitations,
vocally or histrionically skil-fully concealed. Thus it was that light opera
degenerated into musical comedy, for undoubtedly it is a degeneration, and the
productions of recent years are no longer properly to be classed with light
The musical comedy of today partakes of the character of the old German singspiel
or song-play, in which the spoken dialogue was interspersed with musical numbers.
stated, it is a decadent form of comic or light opera and its forte is dramatic
rather than musical, for the music is brought in rather as incidental than as
an integral part of the performance. Many of the popular musical comedies were
first brought out by organizations or clubs connected with well-known societies
and colleges prominent among which are the "Cadets of Boston," the
"Hasty Pudding Club" at Harvard, "Monk and Wig" at University
of Pennsylvania, and "The Strollers" at Columbia. The Boston "Cadets"
particularly have placed many hits to their credit, "1492" and Jack
and the Beanstock being especially successful.
Among all the American light operas those of DeKoven and Herbert are intrinsically
the best, for they are cleverly put together and show the evidence of musicianly
treatment. America. however, has never produced a writer of librettos to at
all compare with W. S. Gilbert of Gilbert and Sullivan fame, and without the
requisite of a good libretto no opera,
no matter what its musical value, can attain to lasting popularity. The operas
of Reginald DeKoven, of which he has written fifteen, have achieved wide popularity.
Robin Hood alone has been enacted more than three thousand times, while
The Fencing Master, The Highwayman (which is considered his best
work), Foxy Quiller, Red Feather, Maid Marion, The Little
Duchess, Rob Roy, and others have all had successful runs. Mr. DeKoven
also has written two ballets The Man in the Moon and The Man in the
Moon, Jr., as well as many songs which have had a large sale. More than
a million copies of Oh, Promise Me
alone have been sold. DeKoven now stands at the head of our writers of popular
music of the better class. He was born in Middletown, Connecticut, in 1859,
and now is a resident of New York.
Victor Herbert, an American by adoption, is another writer who has made a reputation
for himself in the light opera field. Although he has composed more serious
works and has
been associated with musical matters of a higher order he is best known by his
lighter creations. Mr. Herbert is a native of Ireland and first came to this
country in 1886, when he joined the Metropolitan Opera Company in New York.
He for several seasons was first cellist of the Theodore Thomas Orchestra, later
became the conductor of the Symphony Orchestra in Pittsburg, Pennsylvania, which
position he held for a number of years, and then formed an orchestra of his
own in New York. His operas and musical comedies, while possibly not of quite
as high an order as those of DeKoven, are extremely tuneful and pleasing and
always show the touch of the musician. Among the most popular are The Wizard
of the Nile, Serenade, The Idol's Eye, The Fortune Teller,
Babes in Toyland, Babette, It Happened in Nordland, The
Red Mill, Mdlle. Modiste, which latter has served to perfect the
establishing of Fritzi Scheft as a light opera singer.
Three American teams of light opera and musical comedy writers, Smith &
DeKoven, Barnet & Stone, and Pixley & Luders, have become well known;
for the joint works which they have produced have been among the best of their
class. With the work of the librettists we are not especially concerned, notwithstanding
the fact that on the libretto depends to a large extent the success of an opera.
The music of DeKoven as well as that of Victor Herbert, who perhaps is his nearest
competitor, already has been noted. R. A. Barnet's best works undoubtedly are
1492 and Jack and the Beanstock, which latter work developed into
one of the best extravaganzas ever produced on the American stage. Gustave Luders
has many successes placed to his credit, such as Prince of Pilsen, King
Dodo and Grand Mogul.
Edgar Stillman Kelley wrote a comic opera Puritania,which was excellent
musically, but which suffered through the libretto. Sousa has brought out several
operas, El Capitan, The Charlatan, The Bride Elect and
The Free Lance, as well as an extravaganza, Chris and the Wonderful
Lamp, each of which had some success. The youngest
and one of the most typical of musical comedy writers is Geo. M. Cohan. Mr.
Cohan was born at Providence, Rhode Island, on July 4, 1878, and it is most
fitting that his contributions to popular music should catch the American spirit.
The "Yankee Doodle Boy," as he has been called, very aptly describes
both him and his music. Little Johnny Jones, Forty-five Minutes from
Broadway, George Washington, Jr. and Fifty Miles from Boston
have won fame and fortune for him while he is still under thirty.
It is almost impossible to judge of the composer of our current musical comedies,
for so many songs by writers other than the originator are interpolated that
the name of the initiatory writer becomes lost in the hodge-podge finally produced.
The musical comedies of today recall the "Ballad Operas" of more than
a century ago, and it is seen that we thus have reverted to the tastes of our
forefathers. Truly, there is nothing new under the sun. The only difference
to be seen is in the character and make-up of the music itself, for the structure
of musical comedy is very similar to that of the Beggar's Opera.
In the true comic or light opera the librettist aims to form either a consistent
farcical story or a clever satire, but in musical comedy this unfortunately
is hardly considered necessary. So long as there are two or three acts of more
or less amusing dialogue, striking stage pictures and taking music, nothing
more is regarded as of importance. Although not an American production Franz
Lehar's Merry Widow, which has taken the world by storm, may be cited
as a typical light opera of today, while Victor Herbert's Red Mill is
characteristic of musical comedy. The difference in general make-up easily may
be noted and compared.
The enumeration of the musical comedies, writers of such works, and singers
and players appearing in the same within recent years, is out of the question,
for new writers and performers are continually coming forward and the existence
of the works themselves at the best is but a matter of a few years. As representative
writers of musical comedy, beside those already spoken of may be cited Richard
Carle, Gus Edwards, Raymond Hubbell, Joe Howard, A. B. Sloane, Jean Schwartz,
Alfred Robyn and M. Klein. Numbers of adaptations of English, French and German
musical comedies and' extravaganzas" as well as our own products have been
successfully exploited in this country within the last few years. From the time
when Francis Wilson first was brought forward as a star there has been a steady
stream of singers of the lighter musical works who have won fame for themselves
in this field. Some, such as Alice Nielsen, have used the light opera roles
as stepping stones to more ambitious achievements, while there are again others
who have reversed the process. There are many names beside those already enumerated
which have become closely associated with the more popular musical productions
of the American stage. It will suffice to mention the following as representative
of their class: Lillian Russell, Virginia Earle, Fay Templeton, Madge Lessing,
Marie Cahill, Camille D'Arville, Marie Tempest, Edna Wallace Hopper, Lulu Glaser,
Edna May, Jeff De Angelis, De Wolfe Hopper, Richard Carle and Frank Daniels.
It will be seen that the laurels in its field rest with the fair sex. Williams
and Walker occupy a unique place through their excellent presentation of musical
plays by a company composed wholly of negroes.
What will be the next phase to be assumed by popular music in this country is
impossible to state. However, it appears highly probable that within a few years
there will come a revulsion of feeling against the inanities of musical comedy,
and the more legitimate forms of light opera again will assume their place in
public favor. Despite the outcry heard in some quarters against the popular
music of the day, it is serving its purpose in educating the public to desire
something better. Popular music in its various forms alwayswill have a place,
for it is music which the musically uncultured can enjoy. Just as art music
continually is changing its character and structure, so is popular music undergoing
the same evolution, and the last word has not been said in either field. From
the fact that musical culture ever is becoming more general, it is but natural
to assume that the increased familiarity of the public with music of the better
class must have its effect on the popular productions. An unbiased investigator
will find marked improvement in the general trend of popular music produced
in the last twenty-five years, and we still are advancing.
The source of this document is taken from the following book, now in the public
The American History and Encyclopedia Of Music, Hubbard, W.L. Editor
in Chief, 1910, Irving Square, N.Y.C.
All text is as originally published with no editing or abridgement. Images
and music have been added by ParlorSongs for illustrative purposes and were
not a part of the original document .
Read the first installment here.